Skip to main content

Comparison / The energy library

Choosing a heat pump: compare the design, model and support

The product questions that matter beyond a brand ranking: heat loss, output at design conditions, flow temperature, noise and aftercare.

3 min readHome Energy CompareOur editorial approach ↗

The useful starting point

A well-matched heat pump is part of a well-designed heating system. Compare the proposed design and exact model before choosing by a headline efficiency or brand badge.

The home sets the requirement

Start with room-by-room heat-loss calculations, the heat emitters and the hot-water requirement. Bedroom count alone is not a reliable way to choose heat-pump output. Two similarly sized homes can lose heat at different rates.

Ask what output the selected unit delivers at the relevant outdoor and water temperatures. A catalogue model number does not necessarily describe its output at the coldest design condition for your home.

Use a real model as a research starting point

Vaillant’s UK aroTHERM plus information describes an air-to-water system using R290 refrigerant. That identifies a product family, but your proposal still needs an exact unit, cylinder, controls and design.

When comparing it with another manufacturer’s proposal, ask both installers for the same information. A high permitted flow temperature may be useful in a design, but it is not a promise of high efficiency at that temperature. Use the expected seasonal performance for the actual system.

Make a comparison that means something

Ask forWhy it matters
Heat-loss design and selected outputShows why the proposed unit fits the property
Flow temperature and emitter changesConnects comfort requirements with expected efficiency
Minimum output and control strategyHelps explain operation during milder weather
Noise assessment and locationConsiders the proposed installation and neighbours
Hot-water arrangementChecks cylinder capacity, recovery and available space
Warranty and aftercareIdentifies registration, servicing conditions and responsibility for faults

Do not compare unlike noise figures

Sound power and sound pressure are different measurements. A pressure figure also depends on distance and conditions. A table mixing them can appear precise while telling you very little about how an installation will sound.

Ask the designer for the assessment relevant to the planned position. Consider reflective surfaces, sleeping rooms, neighbours and access for maintenance. Do not move a unit to a location that undermines the manufacturer’s clearance or installation requirements.

Put support alongside performance

Ask who commissions the system, explains the weather compensation and returns if rooms do not reach the agreed temperatures. Find out what a service includes, how faults are reported and whether labour and travel are covered under the warranty.

Compare the running-cost assumptions in the heating tool. Then read the installation cost guide so the “cheapest” quote does not simply omit work another installer has included.

This is a buying framework, not a hands-on test or a ranking of every heat pump sold in the UK.

Check the complete proposal.

Published information supports your research. Your installer should confirm the exact product, suitability, scope and terms for your property.

Suggest a correction ↗

Your next useful step

Put the information to work.

Take the questions that matter to your project, explore the numbers and decide what to ask next.